HomepageISTEEdSurge
Skip to content
ascd logo
Log in to Witsby: ASCD’s Next-Generation Professional Learning and Credentialing Platform
Join ASCD
December 1, 2026
•
5 min (est.)
•
Vol. 84
•
No. 4

Invest in Relationships to Spend on Challenge

author avatar
When we put in the work to get to know our students, we build trust we can draw on later.
School Culture & ImprovementStudent Engagement
Photo of teacher Philip Lindsay in the doorway to his classroom, his hands extended in greeting.
Credit: artist / agency name
“I really wanted to, but I didn’t,” one of my students said to me as she walked away from a heated situation with another student. For most students, walking away at that moment wouldn’t have been a big deal, but for this student, it was huge. This 8th-grader had been on my special education caseload since 6th grade. She struggled with regulating her emotions, and we had worked on this, day in and day out. The countless conversations had finally paid off. She did it. She walked away.
I told her how proud I was of her. Then I made the mistake of asking her what she had wanted to do in the moment. “Stab her with my pencil,” she replied. OK. That’s not exactly what I wanted to hear. Still, the fact that she walked away showed growth.
That is one of the things we need to remember as educators: You have to know where someone started to measure how far they’ve come.

Showing It’s Safe to Grow

Because I knew how much my student had worked on managing her emotions, I knew that walking away from a conflict instead of lashing out was a huge win. But to someone who didn’t know her and her struggles, it may not have seemed like the achievement that it was.
Our students are whole people, not just minds disconnected from the world. They bring strengths, weaknesses, challenges, personalities, fears, and needs that don’t show up in their standardized test results. Every student who walks through my classroom door comes with their own unique story. It’s my job to learn that story.
Students, especially those who are struggling emotionally, wear a mask that displays the version of themselves they allow others to see. By getting to know our students and showing them that they are safe, we help them remove that mask. This happens through having conversations about their interests or likes, offering encouraging words, noticing when they may be struggling, and creating spaces in class where they can have fun. Knowing our students enables us to begin guiding them toward who they are meant to be.
I want my students to leave my classroom with a rich understanding of math and how it affects their world, but I also want them to develop into contributing members of society who have dreams—and the resilience and determination to achieve them. I hope they are confident and kind, and I hope to help them learn how to work with others and be productive members of a team. I want them to take risks, think outside the box, and grow.

Every student who walks through my classroom door comes with their own unique story. It’s my job to learn that story.

Author Image

Students will not develop unless we challenge them, but challenge without safety is ineffective. Trust determines how students will receive a challenge. If we want students to trust us enough to step outside their comfort zones, we need to make them feel safe. To earn students’ trust so we can challenge them, we have to truly know them.
Think about a time when someone challenged you without knowing anything about you. How did that make you feel? Challenging students before they trust us can lead to pushback, shutdowns, resistance, defensiveness, and minimal compliance. When we challenge students after building trust, it is a completely different story. Students become far more willing to take risks, persist, show vulnerability, and even enjoy difficult learning.

Building Relational Stock

Investing in our students works like investing in stock: The more we put in, the more we can pull out. Every time we take an interest in something a student cares about, remember something they told us, listen to them, laugh with them, follow through on a promise, or admit when we’re wrong, we make deposits into that relationship.
Eventually we’re going to need to make withdrawals. Those withdrawals are how we push students to grow. They happen when we say things like:
  • “That’s not your best; I know you’ve got more.”
  • “Do it again.”
  • “I’m not lowering my expectation; I want you to rise to it.”
  • “I know this is hard, but it’s worth it.”
  • “I know you’re struggling, but I also know you can do it.”
Growth happens when students are pushed beyond what they think they can do. But if we want students to give us their trust and make themselves vulnerable by really trying, we need to have relational stock to draw against. We build this capital by putting in the work to understand them. If we want to guide students toward their full potential, we must invest in the relationship first.
As a special education teacher, I work with students with disabilities, some of whom have doubted themselves and their abilities for years. One student I worked with struggled with reading and math, and it was easy to assume that their struggle was mostly related to their disability. But after getting to know them, I learned that their 3rd-grade teacher had told them, “You are not good at math,” and they had carried that narrative ever since. Over the three years I worked with this student, I was able to show them they had the skills they needed and encourage them to try more challenging work. If I hadn’t taken the time to pinpoint the reason behind their struggle, I wouldn’t have been able to push them nearly as far as I did.

Making the First Deposits

Not everybody’s approach to building relational stock is going to be the same, but I believe every teacher needs to find what works for them. My approach is humor. Specifically, I try to immerse myself in students’ digital world—not because I’m trying to be cool, but because I need them to see that I take an interest in what’s happening outside the classroom, too.
I was able to get one student to open up by dropping references to TikTok memes. I knew he’d been struggling in class, but every time I asked him if there was anything I could clear up or reteach, he would shrug it off and say he was OK. When I was on lunch duty watching students, I saw how much he was into trending memes. This was my in. Every day when I greeted him at the door, I started dropping a reference to the most obscure meme I could find. After a few days, he started bringing his own references. A few days after that, I approached him to ask if he needed help with an assignment. He explained what he did not understand and asked if he could get another explanation. From that point on, he continued to ask for help and his engagement in my class increased dramatically.

Knowing the meme, understanding the slang, recognizing the trend—all these moves communicate: I see you. I’m interested in what you’re interested in. You can be yourself here.

Author Image

My favorite moments are when a student drops the latest slang word or references a meme and I know what it is. I fire back a quick response, the room loses it in a combination of cringing and astonishment, and we have a shared moment. Students notice when adults understand their world, but they also feel good being the ones to explain something to the “old person” or “unc.” Knowing the meme, understanding the slang, recognizing the trend, letting them explain something—all these moves communicate: I see you. I’m interested in what you’re interested in. You can be yourself here.
Humor and online memes open the door, but connection is the end goal. Once students are comfortable being themselves, you start learning who they really are. If I am interested in what students mean when they say, “That’s so peak,” they are more likely to believe I am truly interested in what they are struggling with mathematically and that I want them to succeed.
My classroom is fun, but my students know I will push and challenge them. They also trust that I will provide the help they need to succeed. Because they trust me, they’re willing to go along for the ride. While humor is my vehicle for creating that sense of trust, connection remains the key. Other teachers might leverage their ability to ask meaningful questions or use a specific hobby or their love of music, art, or sports to create those moments of fun and connection that they can build on.

From Connection to Growth

We want growth, and growth comes from being challenged. We can challenge students when they trust us, and we build trust through connection.
Connection shows us
  • Who needs encouragement vs. accountability.
  • Who shuts down when embarrassed.
  • Who needs to be pushed.
  • Who needs a quieter approach.
  • Who is capable of more than they’re currently giving.
  • Who desperately wants to succeed but is terrified of failing.
Relationships are not separate from instruction; they are the place where we discover what our students need from our instruction. Once we’ve built that connection, the work turns to asking intentional questions, observing student behavior, watching how a student responds when they get something wrong, and formulating a plan based on that information to help them grow.
Sometimes the growth that comes from connection is only evident if we know the student and where they started. Significant growth may not look impressive to someone on the outside, but a teacher who has built relational stock with students knows exactly what’s happening. That’s why knowing our students matters.
When my student told me, “I wanted to, but I didn’t,” I knew exactly how big a deal it was. I remembered joking around in class, making time for extra conversation, and pausing to debrief a difficult moment in class with her. All of this helped me understand what she struggled with, which allowed me to provide support, which led to her trusting me, which led to challenging conversations, which led to real growth.
Connecting with students, using humor, and taking an interest in each student’s world build trust—and once trust is built, the potential for emotional and academic growth is limitless.

Philip Lindsay is a special education math teacher, comedian, speaker, content creator, and former youth pastor.

Learn More

ASCD is a community dedicated to educators' professional growth and well-being.

Let us help you put your vision into action.
Discover ASCD's Professional Learning Services
Related Articles
View all
undefined
School Culture & Improvement
The Anatomy of School Trust
Sarah McKibben
in 2 weeks

Related Articles

From our issue
The magazine cover for the issue "The Trust Factor", featuring two illustrated figures holding a tarp between them to catch the falling words "The Trust Factor"
The Trust Factor
Go To Publication