HomepageISTEEdSurge
Skip to content
ascd logo
Log in to Witsby: ASCD’s Next-Generation Professional Learning and Credentialing Platform
Join ASCD
December 1, 2026
•
5 min (est.)
•
Vol. 84
•
No. 4

Trust Pillars, Trust Killers

author avatar
A few habits can determine whether leaders earn their staff’s trust—or lose it.
School & District Leadership
A photo of two Jenga towers, one solidly assembled, the other toppling.
Credit: New Africa / Adobe Stock
These days, teachers walk into our buildings carrying the weight of an increasingly cynical world. Outside school walls, confidence in public education is eroding, political polarization is high, and our schools—once viewed with reverence and unwavering trust—are under constant scrutiny. Educators are finding our professional judgment questioned at every turn, a reality that can take a personal toll. We become defensive, exhausted, and cautious, and we wonder, Who has my back?
That’s why it is critical that principals prioritize trust. Teachers need to know that within the walls of the school, everyone—the principal, their colleagues—can be trusted.
A trusting school environment certainly makes us feel better, but there are broader implications, too. A meta-analysis of multiple studies found that principals who lead beyond strict management—those who create organizational structures, build instructional systems, and give relevant and timely feedback—have higher student outcomes (Liebowitz & Porter, 2019). Moreover, schools with principals who prioritize collective efficacy and trust have higher graduation rates; ACT results; and scores on English, reading, and mathematics assessments (Bozman Sr., 2011). It’s important for principals to establish and maintain a trusting and reciprocal relationship with the faculty, students, parents, and community. Cultures of collaboration create better results.
So how do principals prioritize building, maintaining, and repairing trust? Let’s think about two very different leaders—one who kills trust and another who actively builds it.

Trust Killers

A colleague once described her former principal’s leadership style in this way:
I didn’t trust him at all. It wasn’t like he was a bad guy. He didn’t do anything nefarious or inappropriate. It was just that he was so conflict-averse that he lied about things. He’d give the exact same positive feedback to every teacher on their evaluation. In discipline situations, he’d call a parent to tell them about a consequence. When the parent pushed back, he’d tell the parent that their child actually hadn’t done anything all that bad, but it was the teachers pushing for a consequence. “My hands are tied,” he’d say. He would do anything to make people happy. He thought he was building trust, but he was doing the opposite. In the end, there was no trust at all.
That’s the irony of trust. Sometimes the easiest path, such as telling people what you think they want to hear, is the thing that kills it.
Here’s another example. Early in my career as an assistant principal, I was desperate to please both staff and parents; I thought if I could make everyone happy, that would be a clear marker of my success. What I didn’t consider is how quickly my people-pleasing would break trust. I remember a tense meeting in which a parent got very aggressive with a teacher, unfairly and irrationally blaming that teacher for her child’s poor behavior. I should have stepped in immediately, setting the expectation for a respectful, cordial conversation and making it clear that we would end the meeting if that standard could not be met. Instead, thinking the parent just needed space to vent, I let the tirade continue.
By the time it was over, the teacher was in tears and left the meeting feeling vulnerable, unsupported, and completely unprotected. That was my fault. I’d killed the trust with the teacher in an attempt to avoid upsetting a parent. I could have avoided it by being clear, firm, and focused on positive outcomes for the student; instead, I created a negative trust dynamic with a staff member that would take years to rebuild.

That’s the irony of trust. Sometimes the easiest path, such as telling people what you think they want to hear, is the thing that kills it.

Author Image

In my book Trusted: Trust Pillars, Trust Killers, and the Secret to Successful Schools (ASCD, 2025), I discuss other trust killers, such as not being open to other people’s ideas; behaving unprofessionally; being unwilling to be vulnerable; being unkind, spiteful, or unreliable; or being incompetent in the work. These are things people notice, and they create resentment that builds over time and leads to damage and broken trust.

Trust Pillars

Consider a second leader, described to me by a colleague I’ll call Shena. “My principal has a great sign on his office wall,” she told me. “It is an acrostic of THINK. It says, ‘Before you speak, ask yourself: Is it true? Helpful? Inspiring? Necessary? Kind? If not, don’t say it.’”
According to Shena, her principal genuinely lives by this approach. “He takes care with every interaction. He doesn’t shy away from difficult conversations. No matter how tough the topic, we know he is a person of integrity. Even if we don’t like the situation or the outcome, we know we can trust that he made the best decision for our school.”
Shena described difficult conversations in which the principal was able to say things no one wanted to hear—yet, when these conversations were over, the sentiment was, “Well, I appreciate his honesty,” and “At least I know where we stand with this.” She told of a time the principal was planning an extended safety training. Several staff members expressed dismay at the amount of time the training would take. The principal acknowledged their frustration in a staff meeting. He was genuine in his empathy, recognizing the work they were anxious about completing.
“It’s also true that school safety training is our highest priority,” he explained. “I would never forgive myself if there were an incident, and we weren’t prepared to handle it. We have to dedicate the hours to do this right.” He was kind, but he was firm in his stance. Were the teachers still wishing they could spend more time in their classrooms? Yes. But they felt heard and understood, and they had an explanation of the principal’s genuine worry about lack of preparedness related to security. The ability for a principal to listen, hear, acknowledge, and explain the rationale for a decision is a primary pillar of trust.
There are several other pillars that leaders can rely upon. Here are a few ideas from Trusted to get you started.
Have an open mindset: This takes more discipline than it sounds. It’s a weakness of mine, actually. I’ll never forget when my then-assistant principal proposed revamping how we distributed our weekly newsletter. “Why?” I asked, reluctantly. “Our current process works fine. I don’t want to change for the sake of change.”
She rolled her eyes. “Trust me,” she said. “You’ll be glad you did.”
Sure enough, the new distribution system worked exponentially better, saving us time and reducing errors. That wasn’t the first time—or the last—when I reacted to innovative ideas with reluctance. My natural inclination is to be overwhelmed by the effort of leading change, rather than envision the improvements and possibility that might come with it. If I keep my mind open to new possibilities, though, it is easier for others to see me as a trustworthy and trust-willing leader.
Be honest and transparent: This doesn’t mean telling the whole truth and nothing but the truth all the time. It means understanding what information is relevant and helpful. It means tackling difficult conversations with honesty and clarity instead of projecting, guessing, or bending the truth.
Display professionalism: We all strive to be professional, but fatigue and frustration happen. We might lose our temper, speak poorly of others, or cut corners. Even a momentary lapse can quickly erode trust and undermine our integrity. We can’t expect professionalism from others if we don’t model it ourselves. Whenever I feel my patience slipping, I step away—I take a walk, close the laptop, or switch tasks. Without exception, I’m always glad I did. Catching yourself before you snap isn’t just helpful; it’s essential.
Be vulnerable: We all have bad days, confusing days, tired days, or times we don’t feel confident. It’s OK to acknowledge these times, because doing so shows a willingness to overcome weaknesses. “I don’t know much about this part of special education compliance,” you might say, “but I’ll dig in and see what I can learn!” Or, “I could have handled that situation a little better. Next time I’ll pause and think before reacting.”
Be reliable: As leaders, others count on us—to be on time for an evaluation conference, to be consistently kind, to be a dependable presence in the lunchroom, to follow through on our promises. If I tell a parent I will call them after school and don’t, they will lose trust in me; it’s likely they will spend the evening waiting for a phone call and grow increasingly frustrated by my broken promise. If I tell a student I’ll be available to discuss a problem and don’t call them down as I promised, they’ll think I don’t care about them. If I schedule an evaluation with a teacher and then don’t show up, the teacher may have prepared (and worried) for days about the observation and feel discarded when I didn’t follow through; worse, they’ll have to go through the entire routine again when I reschedule. In each of these cases, if I don’t have a good reason for not following through and I don’t communicate that reason as soon as possible, the incident will damage the trust these people have in me.

The ability for a principal to listen, hear, acknowledge, and explain the rationale for a decision is a primary pillar of trust.

Author Image

Show grace and positivity: It is difficult to work in an environment where the leader is perpetually negative. Students, teachers, and parents need to see that we understand others’ experiences and offer kindness, empathy, and optimism. A colleague of mine is fond of saying, “When the principal has a cold, the entire school has a cold.” Which is to say the principal’s mindset and behaviors significantly impact the school’s organizational health, teacher practices, and teacher well-being.
Although stress and negativity can compound over time, it helps to remember our feelings should not translate into rigid or negative leadership tactics. I think of a teacher friend of mine who works in a school with students who have significant behavior challenges. She reminds herself daily—sometimes even hourly—that each student is someone’s child and should be treated as if they were her child. “Somebody’s baby,” she whispers to herself when she gets frustrated. I try to emulate that with students and staff, remembering that every single person I lead has a unique need for me to be gracious and hopeful.
Value reciprocity: There are two sides to the trust coin. The first, of course, is being trustworthy. The second is being trust-willing—believing in those around us and allowing them to do their jobs, to be experts in their fields, and to anticipate and accept repercussions of their missteps. Of all the things that might break trust, one of the biggest is to announce that you trust your teachers, students, and parents—and then step in and micromanage everything they do. Instead, we should trust that they will do what is needed to create strong and positive schools. Sure, we may need to guide them and provide opportunities for growth, but then we need to let them do their jobs. That’s what makes trust so valuable—it’s a reciprocal relationship with big benefits on both sides.

A Work in Progress

These steps won’t always work. You won’t always be at your best. You won’t always remember every detail and appointment. You might stumble over your words or not say enough. Trust is tested, challenged, and even broken. It happens. But when it does, all is not lost; trust can be acknowledged, repaired, rebuilt.
And it’s worth it. As we learned earlier, a trusting culture is linked to positive student outcomes. In a climate designed to tear down collective faith in public education, building trust in leadership cannot be left to chance. It must be intentional. After all, every interaction a principal has either introduces a trust killer or reinforces a trust pillar. When we allow small breaches—broken promises, dismissive feedback, or uneven accountability—to slip by, trust is damaged. Conversely, when we double down on our pillars—showing openness, honesty, positivity, and reciprocity—we are strengthening trust. Although we are living in a world where trust seems elusive, I believe, in the end, that school leaders are the real, live, thoughtful, caring, and trustworthy people that our schools need. And what an honor it is to be one of those people.
References

•

Bozman Sr., C. E. (2011). The effects of principals’ leadership styles, teacher efficacy, and teachers’ trust in their principals on student achievement. ProQuest LLC.

•

Liebowitz, D. D., & Porter, L. (2019). The effect of principal behaviors on student, teacher, and school outcomes: A systematic review and meta-analysis of the empirical literature. Review of Educational Research, 89(5), 785–827.

Jen Schwanke, EdD, has been an educator for almost three decades, teaching or leading at all levels. She is the author of Trusted: Trust Pillars, Trust Killers, and the Secret to Successful Schools, four other ASCD books, and hundreds of articles for various education publications.

In addition to providing professional development to districts in the areas of school climate, personnel, and instructional leadership, Schwanke presents at conferences for ISTE+ASCD, NAESP, NASSP, AASA, and various state and national education organizations. She is the co-host of the popular Principal Matters podcast and an instructor in educational administration at The Ohio State University. Schwanke currently serves as a deputy superintendent in Ohio.

Learn More

ASCD is a community dedicated to educators' professional growth and well-being.

Let us help you put your vision into action.
Discover ASCD's Professional Learning Services
Related Articles
View all
undefined
School & District Leadership
A Closer Look at High-Dosage Tutoring
Bryan Goodwin
10 months ago

Related Articles

From our issue
The magazine cover for the issue "The Trust Factor", featuring two illustrated figures holding a tarp between them to catch the falling words "The Trust Factor"
The Trust Factor
Go To Publication