HomepageISTEEdSurge
Skip to content
ascd logo
Log in to Witsby: ASCD’s Next-Generation Professional Learning and Credentialing Platform
Join ASCD
December 1, 2026
•
5 min (est.)
•
Vol. 84
•
No. 4

When Data Starts a Conversation

+2
author avatar
How one district turned strategic planning into an exercise in trust-building.
Family & Community EngagementSchool & District Leadership
Photo composite of three adults in grey-scale gazing up at six colorful notepads positioned like giant mountain peaks.
Credit: Philip_Lustre_Art-Group_Adobe-Stock
“I’ve been working here for over two decades, and this has been one of the most meaningful sessions I’ve been a part of,” said a teary-eyed school staff member. “I feel like I’ve been listened to.”
This was an unexpectedly touching moment in a facilitated discussion in spring 2026 about refreshing the strategic direction of Guilford County Schools in North Carolina. It underscored an important point: dialogue builds trust. School and district leaders often collect feedback as part of their planning processes, but the real trust-building opportunity lies in who is invited to the table, how the data is interpreted, and what happens afterward.
Guilford County Schools’ previous strategic direction, for 2023–26, heavily focused on post-COVID academic recovery. The refresh represented an opportunity to reconsider priorities, especially amid rapid change in both the labor market and technology. During the spring semester of 2026, we listened to students, families, staff, and community members to understand what matters most to them and to shape our strategic direction. This refresh process shows how prioritizing community voices can cultivate a culture of trust and shared ownership during major organizational transitions.

Expanding Who’s Invited to the Table

Engagement efforts often rely on the same “convenient sample” of people who are already involved and close to decision making. This often includes principals, teachers, and students, as well as members of the general public. Expanding the table means making a concerted effort to seek out voices that have not traditionally been centered.
During the strategic direction refresh process, we engaged over 2,300 people through role-specific surveys and targeted focus groups. In addition to gathering survey feedback from our traditional constituent groups, we engaged with those who are often underrepresented in district planning efforts, including Native American families, families of multilingual learners, families of students with special needs, and specialized school staff, such as curriculum facilitators and counselors.
We conducted four targeted focus groups, three in person and one online because of inclement weather, asking about customer service, access to college and career opportunities, and the district’s strategic direction. Participants shared candid feedback about strengths and areas for improvement, reflecting our district’s emphasis on transparency and shared learning. A liaison who helped organize the groups noted, “I felt very encouraged after leaving [the focus group]. A lot of families in our program don’t always feel like they are heard, so it’s such a relief when I hear the opposite feedback.”
Across students, families, staff, and community members, the feedback was largely consistent. Common themes included: learning should be personalized and connected to students’ future college and career pathways; the district needs to provide more real-world, experiential opportunities and communicate about these opportunities in a clear and timely way; and students need a strong academic foundation and a sense of belonging for their future success.

Surveys and focus groups risk becoming an empty formality if participants don’t have real power to affect the outcome.

Author Image

The feedback also enabled us to surface nuances and themes unique to each group we listened to: students’ worries about their future stability in a changing world, the need for consistently translated documents and supports as multilingual students transition across schools, the reality of counselors’ full plates, and the need for more inclusive opportunities for special education students to prepare for life after high school. This thematic analysis informed the district’s strategic direction, validated the quality of our listening, and deepened trust.

The Role of Agency in Trust

Although surveys and focus groups are necessary to understand constituent priorities, they are not sufficient for building trust. Collecting this information risks becoming an empty formality if participants don’t have real power to affect the outcome. Trust grows when the community has an opportunity to advocate, make meaning of the feedback, and shape priorities.
In Guilford County Schools, we established a Strategic Direction Working Group consisting of representatives from the superintendent’s advisory councils, including teachers, principals, nonlicensed employees, family representatives, and external community members. In addition to elevating perspectives specific to their role or group, participants helped synthesize feedback from across the district to identify strengths and opportunities for improvement.
During one workshop, district leaders shared emerging themes, including the need for stronger strategic communication and expanded whole-child supports, as well as proposed shifts in the strategic direction, such as a greater emphasis on durable skills and purposeful pathways. District leadership encouraged open dialogue throughout the process, inviting participants to challenge assumptions and raise concerns before decisions were finalized.
Strategic plan developers often reveal plans only once, at launch, rather than sharing and shaping them formatively with the people most affected. Sharing our thinking in less polished forms required vulnerability from leadership, but it communicated that participant input had real weight and influence.
We also wanted to invite more conversations around the district’s focus on the Guilford Guarantee, which promises that all students will earn at least a semester’s worth of college credit and gain industry credentials and workplace experience before high school graduation. We trained a group of district leaders to facilitate structured small-group conversations among colleagues in similar roles, including school leaders, counselors, curriculum facilitators, teacher leaders, and special populations coordinators.
We asked participants to review data about the Guilford Guarantee and reflect on what resonated with their experiences and what that suggested for their work. Across elementary, middle, and high schools, as well as central office leadership, staff shared their commitment to helping students chart their futures, while also identifying barriers, such as unclear expectations by level, transportation issues, and grade point average constraints in accessing advanced opportunities. These discussions helped build shared understanding around the “why,” reinforcing that the strategic plan was something these educators helped shape, rather than something they were handed. Their feedback is informing the development of experiences from elementary through high school for the Guilford Guarantee.
Participants in the data discussions appreciated that “the data felt realistic [and] needs-based” rather than only showcasing positive opinions. One group of educators shared, “[We are] often talked at and never really given an opportunity to discuss [with] colleagues what [we’re] learning and seeing.” The collaborative discussion was a welcome departure from status ­quo, sit-and-get meetings. At the end of the conversations, participants made concrete recommendations for improvement, including encouraging shared accountability for the Guilford Guarantee and connecting individuals and departments across academics and operations to this vision.

Sharing our thinking in less polished forms communicated that participant input had real weight and influence on the strategic direction.

Author Image

Many staff members shared that this was one of the first times they were directly involved in shaping district strategy. Although many had heard of the Guilford Guarantee, they weren’t well-versed in the specific strategies underlying the initiative, why the strategies mattered, or how they applied to them.
These data-reflection conversations became an opportunity to build coherence because they called for specific and clear action, both individually and collectively, in defining what the Guilford Guarantee looks like at each level and removing barriers to student access. When people shape the vision and understand their part in it, they feel included and invested in the big-picture strategy. Coherence begets trust, and trust begets coherence (Fullan & Quinn, 2016).

Following Up—and Following Through

Sending one’s feedback into a black box and never knowing what came of it leads to frustration and degrades trust. Why share honest input if no one is going to do anything with it?
Participants in our discussion groups wanted to see the results of their feedback, so we met with them again to share emerging themes and provide clarity on next steps. Clarifying when follow-up will occur and designating a specific time on calendars can go a long way toward reassuring constituents that you’re taking their voices into consideration.

Trust and Transparency

As our district implements key strategies like the Guilford Guarantee, the trust we’ve built is tested, especially in light of constrained resources. Trust is hard to sustain when leaders cannot immediately deliver what constituents want.
Recently, our district has been navigating a challenging budget environment that threatens our ability to deliver on priorities such as school safety and staff pay raises. In moments like these, our leaders maintain trust through transparency. Superintendent Whitney Oakley (one of the co-authors) has communicated budget realities to staff, families, and the community through superintendent advisory council meetings, board of education meetings, staff communications, and media interviews, while acknowledging the resulting uncertainty, disappointment, and frustration. When constituents understand how tough decisions are made and how leaders must consider competing priorities, they’re more likely to trust the resulting decisions.

Trust as Leadership Work

Organizational change happens more readily when people trust one another. Communication is more open, decisions happen more quickly, and people can move forward with shared direction, alignment, and commitment (Drath et al., 2008). The call for leadership is to create opportunities for people to contribute and recognize their own influence over decisions. Here are some lessons we’ve learned for building trust:
  • Consider whose voices have been weighed when making strategic decisions. Be sure to fold a broad range of participants into the conversation so plans are shaped by their input, rather than simply imposed on them.
  • Create feedback loops. Don’t assume that asking for input once is sufficient. Instead, follow up with participants to share emerging themes and ask for additional thoughts and ideas.
  • Communicate continuously, especially when times are tough. When districts face budget challenges and other shortfalls, ongoing communication acknowledging the difficult reality can help others understand how tough decisions are made.
Sharing input this way fosters goodwill, and goodwill builds trust, which enables us to gather more candid feedback. In this way, the cycle continues—and our students benefit.
References

•

Drath, W. H., McCauley, C. D., Palus, C. J., Van Velsor, E., O’Connor, P. M. G., & McGuire, J. B. (2008). Direction, alignment, commitment: Toward a more integrative ontology of leadership. The Leadership Quarterly, 19(6).

•

Fullan, M., & Quinn, J. (2016). Coherence: The right drivers in action for schools, districts, and systems. Corwin.

Erin Philip-James is the director of strategic planning and special projects for Guilford County Schools and an alumna of the Harvard Strategic Data Project Fellowship.

Learn More


ASCD is a community dedicated to educators' professional growth and well-being.

Let us help you put your vision into action.
Discover ASCD's Professional Learning Services
From our issue
The magazine cover for the issue "The Trust Factor", featuring two illustrated figures holding a tarp between them to catch the falling words "The Trust Factor"
The Trust Factor
Go To Publication