Every day in classrooms, teachers introduce students to new information and skills, but the real pedagogical work begins later, after the first assessments reveal what students have and haven’t yet learned. In nearly every assessment, the teacher seeks to surface students’ misconceptions and use that information to target their knowledge and skill gaps. And in every assessment, students risk revealing, through their mistakes, their incomplete knowledge or misunderstandings. It is a vulnerability teachers expect and depend on: “Trust me,” the teacher implies, “and I will help you.”
Indeed, trust—the willingness to rely on and be vulnerable to others and then to take risks—is an integral element of effective classrooms and schools. It is, in many ways, “the centre of the school experience” (Ennis & McCauley, 2002). Trusting teacher-student relationships support higher student achievement (Syahabuddin et al., 2020), increase the well-being of both students and teachers (Hongwidjojo et al., 2018), and improve student engagement and motivation (Estepp & Roberts, 2015). For students who have had few trusting relationships with adults or who have learned to distrust adults, building trust is crucial to unlocking their sense of hope and a belief in their potential to succeed (Ennis & McCauley, 2002).
Although teachers tend to build trusting relationships with students through supportive, respectful conversations and culturally relevant curriculum and instruction, they don’t often look at grading practices as a strategy to build trust. The assumption is that grading is technical and peripheral to the student-teacher relationship. However, teachers’ grading choices can either generate trust or erode it.
Excluding Homework from the Grade: An Invitation to Be Vulnerable
When a student considers whether to actively engage in learning, they weigh the potential consequences of exposing their misunderstandings (Ennis & McCauley, 2002): If I make a mistake or reveal I don’t know, will the teacher respond with understanding and support, or with indifference or punishment? Teachers, informed by growth mindset research, encourage students to take this risk and to accept mistakes as normal and valuable (Dweck & Leggett, 1988). We want to show students they can rely on us to respond to their mistakes with reteaching and support, not with penalty.
Yet we often use grading practices that send the opposite message: Your mistakes are unwanted, and, if you risk showing them, you will be punished for that vulnerability. We want students to be vulnerable, but our grading tells them not to be.
Take the common practice of including homework or classwork performance in the grade, subtracting points for errors or incomplete work. When we do this, we penalize students during the stage of learning when they are most vulnerable. Although knowledge gaps at the end of the learning process—on summative assessments—should be reflected in the grade, when mistakes during the learning process are included, students get the message that mistakes are always punished and should be avoided or even hidden from us.
Viewed through this lens, students we often characterize as “lazy” or “refusing to learn” might, in fact, be reacting to grading policies that penalize mistakes during learning. Under these circumstances, refusing to participate in a discussion or not submitting homework may well be rational and self-preserving decisions motivated by “failure avoidance” (Covington, 2007). Rather than turn in incorrect answers that result in a lower grade, students refuse to take risks to avoid any “disclosure of incompetency” (Covington, 1984).
We want students to be vulnerable, but our grading tells them not to be.
Our grading structures should encourage risk-taking rather than punish it. Excluding homework and classwork from the grade treats those assignments entirely as practice opportunities. Teachers still assign homework and classwork, expect students’ best effort, and even record students’ performance in the gradebook—but they don’t include it in the grade calculation.
This approach to grading creates a virtuous cycle of trust for the student (Normann et al., 2023): I show vulnerability, and because I’m helped, not harmed, I take more risks and reveal more, both in my learning and in my relationships with my teacher. It also surfaces more honest communication from students; they become more willing to share not only their confusions, but also the personal circumstances behind an incomplete assignment.
In our partnerships with schools, we have found that teachers are frequently skeptical about not including homework in the grade. They often believe that students won’t do the homework, that lessons depending on homework will flop, or that students won’t learn the content for the summative assessment. Underneath these worries is often a sense of distrust: We don’t trust students to be self-motivated without the carrot or stick of a grade. Just as students may distrust us teachers based on previous experiences or stories they’ve heard, we may distrust them based on our previous experiences or what others have told us.
Ungraded Student Behaviors: Trust vs. Control
Another common grading practice is to award or subtract points for students’ behavior. This might relate to the learning process, like taking notes or participating in class discussions, or to classroom comportment or citizenship, like arriving on time or not interrupting others. We use these grades to reward students when they behave in ways we prefer—and to punish them when they don’t. But as middle school science teacher Vicki Baker pointed out, “A lot of what I see teachers doing is using grades to control behaviors. Once you see that, you can’t unsee that” (personal communication, 2017).
Grading students’ behavior is usually driven by good intentions: we want to teach them how to behave in ways that improve learning and prevent disruptive behaviors. But this grading practice assumes that students will not behave in preferred ways (as we define them) and that we must rely on grading to control their behavior.
A widely cited synthesis of research about trust in K–12 schools (Tschannen-Moran & Hoy, 2000) shows that distrust provokes anxiety and less willingness to take risks; it causes people to “expend energy on monitoring the behavior and possible motives of others.” When teachers create complicated systems of awarding or subtracting points—for contributing to a discussion, asking questions, bringing materials, or coming to class on time—they create a vicious cycle of distrust-control-distrust. Students either adhere to the behavioral rules and receive positive grades or violate them and receive lower grades; either way, the results seem to demonstrate the grading policy’s effectiveness. According to Tschannen-Moran and Hoy (2000), this approach, once established, “has a strong tendency to be self-perpetuating.”
When you trust, you cannot control, and when you control, you cannot trust.
Ironically, by distrusting students enough to feel we need to grade their behaviors, we never give them the opportunity to demonstrate that they don’t need to have their behaviors graded. We have built self-reinforcing systems of distrust. Teachers who use grades to control behavior may appear to have an effective classroom—students follow expectations and the classroom functions without challenge—but they have, in fact, sacrificed opportunities for building trusting relationships. As Ennis and McCauley (2002) note,
Although controlling and confining measures often make adults feel more secure, it is only a temporary illusion of safety and one that may thwart efforts to connect and build relationships with students who are most in need of this care. (p. 170)
The same holds true for homework. If we always include homework performance in the grade, we never give students the opportunity to show they can be trusted to do the homework. As science teacher Clancy Griggs (personal communication, 2019) explains,
When I stopped including homework in the grade, it was a difficult shift for some students because it’s so different from what they’re used to. Now they see the purpose of the homework is actually to learn the material. It’s not about going through the motions or finding ways of copying the homework, which really is doing nobody any good—and it’s no longer worth points anyway. I’ve told the students that the homework is your opportunity to practice and to see how well you understand these things. Homework completion at first took a dip when I stopped counting it for points, but then students realized that “Oh, I want to get a good grade in this class. I need to understand the material,” and then homework completion shot up. It’s the opposite of what I feared would happen.
The Reciprocity of Trust
So how can we find a way out of a vicious cycle of distrust and into a virtuous cycle of trust? How can our grading practices not just encourage students to trust us—but enable us to trust them? We can do this by giving students opportunities to generate evidence that contradicts our prior experiences and assumptions. As educator and researcher Virginia Durnford (2010) explains,
Trust in a teacher-student relationship is a circular, interdependent, dynamic phenomenon. As the student demonstrates qualities of honesty, openness, competence, reliability, and positive motivation, the teacher begins to develop trust in the student. As the teacher expresses her trust in the student, the student may respond with an increase in trustworthy behaviors. (p. 42)
By not including behavior or homework in the grade, we show students that we believe they can behave positively and hand in work because they want to improve their learning. This feels risky, and that’s exactly the point. If we truly want a classroom culture of trust, then we, too, have to be willing to be vulnerable. We may be using grading to control students to minimize our risk. Control acts as a substitute for trust: when you trust, you cannot control, and when you control, you cannot trust (Six, 2018). This unpredictability we seek to control, however, is one of the challenges and joys of teaching.
Taking this risk doesn’t mean changing grading overnight. Teachers need to have honest conversations with students about class goals and how certain behaviors will help them achieve those goals. Teachers might ask the class, “Why would you do homework if it’s not included in the grade? How is this similar to practicing shooting free throws in the backyard, where the points aren’t worth anything but the practice prepares you to perform well in the game?” Or they might share data on the number of students who got an A on the quiz who did both homework assignments. Most important, they invite students’ perspectives. Students might suggest that the rollout occurs in stages or that the teacher sends a letter home to parents to clarify the new policy. Teachers build trust by ceding some control to students, being vulnerable, and signaling that they trust students and that students can trust them. As Durnford (2010) warns,
Teachers who are unable to manage their students without resorting to controlling behaviors lose an opportunity to teach attributes of trust, which students will need to be successful in the world. (p. 141)
Of course, changing grading won’t instantly result in every student behaving productively and completing every assignment. Teachers often see a short-term dip in engagement and homework submission. This is expected: students are reorienting themselves from a grading system of control, compliance, and dependence—the one they’ve known for years—to a system of trust, self-regulation, and accountability. These present-day workplace skills are valuable for students.
Do we believe that students are incapable of self-regulation and can’t be trusted, necessitating that we include homework and learning behaviors in the grade? Or do we believe they can understand that homework helps them (not us), that certain behaviors improve their learning, and that they don’t need us to control them through our grading?
That’s the thing about trust: Whichever option we believe, we’ll be right.