Traditional views of teaching characterize it as an independent skill. But teachers are more effective if they have opportunities to learn from one another and work toward common goals (Schleifer et al., 2017). The skills and resources teachers gain through social connections are more strongly related to student achievement than individual teachers’ educational attainment (Pil & Leana, 2009). If teachers are going to engage in constructive criticism, openly share skills and resources, and build a shared understanding of good practice, they need to be able to trust each other. Anthony Bryk and Barbara Schneider’s (2002) work in Chicago found that schools with stronger relational trust were most likely to show sustained growth over time, because trust enables educators to repeatedly take the risks necessary for improvement.
Teachers can become more collaborative and trusting when their work is interdependent. One way to build interdependence is through a form of team teaching in which two or more teachers share responsibility for a common group of students. Teams coordinate instruction, grouping, planning, and assessment as a collective unit.
Unlike traditional collaboration models or professional learning communities (PLCs), where teachers meet but remain responsible for their individual classrooms, teachers on interdependent teams rely on their teammates to complete tasks and achieve goals. They experience success or failure not as individuals but as a collective (Maddin et al., 2025).
Why Traditional Collaboration Falls Short
Research finds that schools with strong collaboration have better academic outcomes among students, lower teacher turnover, and stronger teacher commitment to their school and the profession (Schleifer et al., 2017). Yet Judith Warren Little’s (1990) classic examination of teachers’ professional relationships illustrates how norms of privacy are pervasive in teaching. Teachers may gather in groups to learn, plan, or analyze data, but then they disperse to their own classrooms, working in whatever way they choose. When these norms persist, collaborative efforts amount to little more than sharing stories or ideas, rather than authentic joint work.
If teachers trust one another, they are more likely to open their classrooms, communicate honestly about their challenges, and offer peers constructive feedback. Without trust, these behaviors feel too risky. When teachers have too much agency to follow their own preferences and not enough guidance or structure for working together, collaboration can devolve into wasted time and effort.
To address this problem, some leaders mandate and micromanage the structures, processes, and goals for teacher collaboration. Andy Hargreaves (2021) calls this “contrived collegiality,” a form of collaboration imposed from above rather than emerging from teachers’ own professional needs and judgment. Contrived collegiality often makes collaboration feel like something teachers must comply with, whether or not it fits their needs or goals. In this case, there is too much structure without enough teacher agency.
If teachers trust one another, they are more likely to open their classrooms, communicate honestly about their challenges, and offer peers constructive feedback.
More effective collaboration requires both structure and agency. For example, lesson study, instructional rounds, Data Wise (a project from the Harvard Graduate School of Education), and other protocols and processes give teachers a structure for collaboration and the agency to identify authentic problems they want to explore. Still, it takes a lot of time and effort to learn these kinds of models. And teachers within a PLC may not share common goals or contexts or have the same ability and motivation to follow through on the learning.
Breaking the Traditional Structure
Attempts to encourage collaboration come up against the same problem: traditional “egg-crate” classrooms in which a single teacher operates in their own compartment with their own set of students (Torres & Laski, 2024). Regardless of the collaborative structures put in place, teachers often have substantial individual autonomy to close their door and decide what and how to teach. For busy teachers, this often means defaulting to their status quo, because trying new things is uncertain and takes substantial time and effort.
In contrast, teachers on interdependent teams share students and goals across classrooms, often with each teacher taking responsibility for a different aspect of their shared work. Students and teachers may move within and among classrooms, depending on the specific activity and students’ needs. When designed well and with proper support, interdependent teams can break the egg-crate dynamic because one person’s work depends on another person completing their part. This is what researchers call “task dependency” (Somech, 2008).
For instance, each team member might be assigned primary responsibility for different teaching tasks, such as lesson plans, graphic organizers, copies, and assessments or exit tickets. If everyone follows through, they are more likely to meet their shared goals. On the other hand, if the person responsible for collecting assessment data does not bring it to a meeting, the team cannot coordinate data-driven student grouping.
This is where trust becomes essential. Because they share the same students, teachers must constantly adjust to each other in ways that are not necessary when each person has their own classroom and students.
Brent Maddin and colleagues of the Next Education Workforce (2025) at Arizona State University use a football analogy to describe the difference between interdependent teams and traditional models. Traditional forms of collaboration are like practicing football together and then attempting to play the game independently, whereas teaming means practicing together then playing the game together. In the latter arrangement, responsibility for performance is shared, and individual results depend on how other team members show up. Table 1 summarizes the differences.
Collaboration and Trust on Interdependent Teams
To understand how teachers are implementing and experiencing new models of teaming, I spent the last year with four high-functioning grade-level elementary teams in two different Michigan districts. I observed classrooms, recorded team meetings, and interviewed team members to better understand what they were doing, why, and what they thought about the work and its impact on them and their students.
These teams had been working together for more than two years, sharing responsibility for all students across their grade level. In both districts, teams had common planning time and used it to group and regroup students, plan, and divide tasks and responsibilities. They had to meet informally and often outside of formal planning time but seemed invigorated by these added interactions.
When I first started getting to know these teams, I was immediately struck by the positivity they expressed toward teaming. Many said they felt like they were constantly learning from each other. They appreciated being able to distribute work according to their strengths and preferences, and they felt a sense of camaraderie as they worked toward shared goals.
Teachers told me that prior to teaming it was possible to simply close their door and ignore or put off next steps in plans they made in PLCs. But in teams, others depended on them, so if they didn’t follow through, it had a tangible impact on their colleagues.
For example, one teacher recalled dropping the ball during a meeting because she was late preparing student data, which affected the team’s ability to make decisions about instruction and student grouping. This made her feel guilty, but when she tried to take the blame, her team refused to blame her and said, “We’re all in this together.”
In this sense, having interdependent goals and tasks facilitated mutual accountability and urgency for the work. Another teacher explained it this way: because everyone has “ownership of all the students’ achievement . . . your bar has to rise up.” For their teams to function, teachers had to both be trustworthy and trust others.
The Power of Trust
In the foreword to Vivian Troen and Katherine Boles’s (2012) The Power of Teacher Teams, Harvard’s Richard Elmore states, “Relational trust among teachers, and between administrators and teachers, is positively related to student performance in schools, and trust is constructed through face-to-face collaborative work.” Trust grows through frequent, daily interactions (Bryk & Schneider, 2002), and teaming provides numerous opportunities for teachers to trust. Team members must constantly collaborate, troubleshoot, coteach, and step in for each other, building strong, trusting relationships in the process.
A teacher explained it this way: because everyone has “ownership of all the students’ achievement . . . your bar has to rise up.”
Several teachers at the Michigan schools described how team members helped them out and stepped in for them when they were having a tough day or if they made a mistake. For example, when coteaching, team members often stepped up to help with student behavior or confer with students who needed additional support, making it easier for the teacher in front of the room. Going through challenging experiences together created a sense of solidarity and reduced the sense of isolation that is pervasive in teaching.
Being interdependent meant that, whenever possible, tasks and roles were assigned based on what team members were good at or had an interest in. Some tasks that individual teachers had previously done for their own classrooms were instead distributed and completed on behalf of the entire team. For example, some teachers who were good with technology managed data systems and presentations while others created materials and made copies or spearheaded family communication and event planning. This made the work more manageable and enjoyable because teachers could lean into their strengths and rely on others to share the load.
Having interdependent tasks and goals meant that teachers’ collaborative work felt relevant and purposeful to everyone. In fact, every team said they wanted more time together to coordinate their collective work. Although distributing responsibilities between individual team members created some efficiency, interdependent work meant higher levels of communication and coordination. Yet team members seemed more than willing to take this on because their work together felt purposeful.
Laying the Foundation for Effective Teaming
A lot of groundwork is necessary to lay the foundation for teams to function as effectively as those I observed in Michigan (Maddin et al., 2025). For example, teams need to agree on goals and methods and set norms for discussing problems openly and challenging each other when necessary. All of these activities require strong coaching and leadership (Hackman, 2002).
Without the right conditions in place, teams experience problems, such as resistance to feedback, vague assignments, unfair distribution of work, and disagreement about the ends and means of the team’s work (Somech, 2008). The teams I studied sometimes had differences of opinion regarding how to address problems with parents or students or who should take on a particular task. In these cases, leaders acted as coaches to help the team navigate conflict openly and productively.
When teams function well, they can strengthen teacher trust and make collaboration purposeful, both of which can help improve schools and systems at scale (Bryk & Schneider, 2002; Schleifer et al., 2017). Early research on interdependent teaming shows positive results for teacher satisfaction, autonomy, and retention (Ingersoll & Audrain, 2025).
For schools considering this approach, the Next Education Workforce often recommends “starting at the speed of trust,” identifying educators who are willing to work together as a team and sending them to schools with high-functioning teams so they can see how the work is done. This helps prospective teams understand, plan, and experiment with how the structure might work in their own contexts. It is often difficult to break out of the traditional norms and “egg-crate” structures of teaching, yet schools and districts across the country are increasingly implementing teams, and they can show others the way forward.