HomepageISTEEdSurge
Skip to content
ascd logo
Log in to Witsby: ASCD’s Next-Generation Professional Learning and Credentialing Platform
Join ASCD
December 1, 2026
•
5 min (est.)
•
Vol. 84
•
No. 4

The True Test of Trust

author avatar
Credibility is often built in the moments leaders would rather avoid.
School & District Leadership
Photo of a small white dog peeking nervously around a corner.
Credit: Anna_Averianova_shutterstock
A teacher finds out through a teammate that the principal is considering moving her to a different grade level next year. A department chair raises a concern in a meeting and is later described as “negative” for questioning the plan. A teacher files a discrimination complaint and hears nothing for several weeks, leaving colleagues to wonder whether anything is happening. A principal realizes after the fact that she gave a teacher incorrect guidance and has to decide whether to quietly correct it or acknowledge the mistake directly.
At first glance, none of these moments look like a major test of organizational culture. But they are.
We often talk about trust as something leaders build through visibility, relationships, and a positive school climate. All of those things matter. But trust is rarely won or lost during the staff breakfast, the team-building activity, or the carefully planned opening-day speech. Trust is tested when the decision is unpopular, the facts are incomplete, the process is confidential, or the leader realizes they handled a situation poorly.
These are the moments leaders would often prefer to avoid. They are also the moments employees are most likely to remember.
I have spent much of my career working in school leadership and employee relations. Across both roles, I have learned that people do not expect every leadership decision to benefit them. They do not even expect leaders to have an immediate answer to every question. What they remember is how a leader behaves when the answer they need to deliver is difficult or unpopular. Those moments reveal whether a leader is willing to be direct, explain the reasoning behind a decision, apply a process consistently, and stay engaged after the decision is made. That is where trust is often won or lost. People may disagree with the outcome and still respect the leadership behind it when they believe they were treated fairly, told the truth, and not avoided once the conversation became uncomfortable.

Trust Is Not the Same as Agreement

Leaders sometimes evaluate how well they communicate by whether people respond positively. If the meeting ended quietly, the email did not generate complaints, or the decision moved forward, they assume their message was successful.
But silence is not always agreement, and agreement is not the best measure of trust. Employees may be hesitant to question a decision directly, but that does not mean they aren’t talking about it. The people affected will discuss every leadership decision you make. The question is whether that conversation happens in your office or in the teachers’ lounge. A lack of pushback does not mean the underlying concern is gone. And agreement is not necessarily permanent. Employees may welcome a change at first, only to become skeptical when the rationale shifts, expectations are applied inconsistently, or promised follow-up never comes.

The goal of a difficult conversation is not to make everyone happy. The goal is to make the process understandable, the communication honest, and the treatment respectful.

Author Image

Research on relational trust in schools has long identified respect, personal regard, competence, and integrity as central features of trustworthy relationships among members of a school community (Bryk & Schneider, 2002). More recent research emphasizes the importance of consistency, authentic relationships, support, respect, and employees feeling heard (Vo et al., 2026).
Trust does not require employees to believe every decision is the one they would have made. In fact, a leader can make a decision employees dislike and still strengthen trust. To accomplish this, leaders have to consistently show that they will be truthful about what they can share, use defensible processes, treat people with dignity, and follow through on their commitments.
For leaders, then, the goal of a difficult conversation is not to make everyone happy. The goal is to make the process understandable, the communication honest, and the treatment respectful. That is a more realistic standard than making everyone happy. It is also a much harder one to meet.
These principles are easy to agree with in theory, but when a leader has to make a decision that affects someone’s schedule, responsibilities, or workload, they become much harder to implement. And yet, those moments are when employees begin deciding whether they trust not only the decision, but the person making it.
Consider a few common school leadership moments where trust can either be strengthened or weakened.

Moment 1: The Unpopular Decision

Imagine an elementary principal has to change several grade-level assignments because enrollment has shifted. A teacher who has taught 3rd grade for years is being moved to kindergarten. Another teacher who loves 1st grade is being reassigned to 4th grade. From a staffing standpoint, the changes may be completely reasonable. But for the teachers involved, the move can feel much bigger than a simple scheduling adjustment. They may be leaving a grade level they know well, curriculum they have mastered, teammates they trust, and routines they have spent years building.
The principal could send an email late Friday afternoon announcing the new assignments, explain that the changes are necessary “to meet the needs of students,” and invite employees to reach out with questions. Technically, the information has been communicated.
But the real conversation is just beginning.
Teachers start comparing what they know. Why was one person moved and another left in place? When was the decision made? Were other options considered? Was experience taken into account? Did anyone have input? “Meeting the needs of students” may be completely true, but without more context, it can sound like a phrase chosen to end the conversation rather than explain the decision.
Alternatively, the principal can speak privately with the affected teachers before releasing the full list of assignments. She can explain what changed, what staffing constraints informed the decision, what had already been decided, and where there was still room for input. She can also acknowledge the impact plainly: “I know this is not the assignment you hoped to receive.”
The decision may still be unpopular, but the second approach gives teachers something the first does not: evidence that the leader considered both the organizational need and the people affected by it.
That is where fairness becomes about more than whether someone received the outcome they wanted. Research on procedural justice in schools suggests that employees’ perceptions of whether decision-making processes are fair and legitimate can shape important aspects of professional life (Liu & Hallinger, 2024). Recent relational-trust research similarly highlights the value of clear expectations, consistency, and predictable processes (Vo et al., 2026).
By communicating the context around the decision and clarifying what was and was not negotiable, the leader is working to preserve trust even when the outcome is unwelcome. That does not mean disclosing private information or inviting a staffwide vote on every operational decision. It means communicating as much as can responsibly be shared and being clear about the limits.
A trustworthy explanation often clarifies:
  • What changed and why a decision became necessary.
  • Which criteria or constraints informed the decision.
  • What has already been decided.
  • Where employee input can still have influence.
  • When employees can expect additional information.
Note that timing is also a factor in building trust. Leaders sometimes withhold communication until they have every answer. The intent may be good, but silence creates a vacuum. In schools and organizations, vacuums rarely remain empty. They fill quickly with speculation, screenshots, and at least one group text that somehow knows more than the official communication. Instead of waiting until you have every piece of information, be honest about what you do and do not know and when you plan to follow up.

Moment 2: The Pushback

During a staff meeting, a teacher questions a new procedure that changes how planning time will be used. The principal believes the rationale has already been explained and hears the question as resistance. The teacher believes a legitimate concern is being dismissed and presses harder.
Within seconds, the conversation is no longer about the policy. It is about whether questioning the policy is psychologically safe.

Leadership advice tends to focus on making good decisions. Less attention is given to what happens after leaders make a poor one.

Author Image

Psychological safety is, at its simplest, whether people believe they can ask a hard question, raise a concern, acknowledge uncertainty, or admit a mistake without paying for it later. Research has connected psychological safety with speaking up, learning, collaboration, and adaptation under uncertainty (Edmondson & Bransby, 2023).
Not every comment is appropriate, not every objection is correct, and not every decision must be reopened because someone disagrees. But to build trust in a moment of pushback, a leader must show that respectful disagreement is accepted and not treated as disloyalty.
The leader’s response in a public moment teaches everyone in the room what happens to people who raise concerns. A defensive response may end the discussion quickly: “We have already talked about this, and the decision has been made.” A trust-building response does something different: “The decision has been made, but your concern about how it will affect planning time is fair. I do not have enough information to answer that well right now. Let me follow up tomorrow.”
Of course, the follow-up must actually happen. Otherwise, “Let me get back to you” becomes leadership’s version of, “We should get lunch sometime.”
Employees do not need leaders to agree with every concern. They need to see that raising a legitimate concern leads to consideration rather than retaliation, avoidance, or a change in how the employee is treated. The most credible leaders can separate the discomfort of being challenged from the responsibility to listen.

Moment 3: The Confidential Process

Some of the hardest trust tests occur when a leader cannot share the full story.
Imagine a teacher reports that a colleague has made repeated comments she believes are discriminatory and has created a hostile work environment. Other teachers know there has been tension. A few may have witnessed parts of it. They know the teacher met with the principal or HR. Then, from their perspective, nothing happens.
Behind the scenes, the concern may be under review. Teachers may be interviewed. Emails or other records may be examined. HR may be determining whether the conduct violates district policy or applicable law. But because much of that process is appropriately confidential, other staff members may interpret the silence as inaction.
This is where leaders sometimes make one of two mistakes. They either disclose too much in an attempt to prove that the concern was addressed, which can compromise confidentiality and undermine the integrity of the process. Or they say almost nothing and assume employees will trust the process, which can leave staff believing the concern was ignored or never taken seriously.
Confidential does not have to mean invisible. A principal cannot tell the faculty whether another teacher was disciplined, what witnesses said, or how credibility was assessed. But the principal can explain what teachers should expect when concerns involving discrimination, harassment, or other serious workplace misconduct are raised.
A leader may be able to say, “I cannot discuss the details of an individual personnel matter. I can tell you that the concern was received, it was reviewed through the appropriate process, and the people directly involved were informed of the outcome.”
That response will not satisfy everyone’s curiosity, but it does communicate that the concern did not simply disappear once it was reported.
Leaders also need to be careful about what they promise at the beginning of a complaint. “We will take this seriously and review it appropriately” is a commitment to process. “We will take care of this” may be heard as a promise that a particular finding or disciplinary outcome will occur. A fair process cannot begin with a predetermined ending.

Moment 4: The Mistake Made

Leadership advice tends to focus on making good decisions. Less attention is given to what happens after leaders make a poor one.
Perhaps, as shared above, a principal announces a staffing change before speaking directly with the teacher most affected. Perhaps a teacher raises a concern about a new expectation and later learns that the principal had relied on the wrong policy guidance. Or perhaps a principal tells a teacher, “I’ll get back to you by Friday,” and Friday comes and goes with no follow-up.

Teachers experience a school through hundreds of small moments that tell them what it is like to work there, what the culture is, and how they are valued (or not).

Author Image

The instinct may be to minimize the mistake, explain away the competing demands in a defensive tone, or quietly correct the problem and move forward without acknowledging what happened.
In these situations, what damages trust is often not the original mistake alone, but what happens when the leader is questioned about it. If the response is to dig in, deflect, or explain why the mistake was understandable, the conversation can quickly become about the leader’s defensiveness rather than the issue itself.
A meaningful repair to a mistake can be remarkably simple. As a school leader, you can say, “I handled that poorly. You should have heard the information from me before the larger announcement. I cannot change the decision, but I can acknowledge that the way I communicated it was not fair to you. I am sorry. Going forward, if a decision directly affects your assignment, I will speak with you before it is communicated more broadly.”
There is no paragraph beginning with “However.” There is no detailed tour of the leader’s calendar. There is no suggestion that the employee misunderstood what happened. Instead, this response reflects two qualities that are at the heart of relational trust: integrity and respect (Bryk & Schneider, 2002). It also models the openness to error and uncertainty associated with psychologically safer workplaces (Edmondson & Bransby, 2023).
Leaders sometimes fear that admitting a mistake will weaken trust. But teachers may be more troubled by a principal who will not admit to being wrong and who becomes increasingly defensive when challenged.
Teachers do not trust school leaders because they are perfect. They trust leaders who own their mistakes, acknowledge the impact of them, repair what they can, and show through their future actions that they learned from what happened.

Trust Compounds

Compensation, workload, working conditions, and opportunities for professional growth all matter to teacher retention. Research consistently confirms the importance of those conditions to teachers’ job satisfaction, well-being, and decisions about whether to remain in their schools or in the profession (Arnold & Rahimi, 2025; Farahmandpour & Voelkel, 2025; Toropova et al., 2021).
Relationships with leaders are part of those working conditions, too. Teachers experience a school through hundreds of small moments that tell them what it is like to work there, what the culture is, and how they are valued (or not). They ask themselves, Can I ask a hard question here? Do the stated rules match what actually happens? Will someone do what they promised after the meeting ends?
No single unanswered email creates a culture of distrust, just as no single apology creates a culture of trust. These moments compound.
That is encouraging because it means trust does not require a new initiative, a branded framework, or another committee. Principal and district leaders can begin with the next difficult conversation already waiting on their calendars. They can say what they know, name what they do not know, and explain what will happen next.
Then, perhaps most importantly, they can do what they said they would do.
That is the real leadership moment.
References

•

Arnold, B., & Rahimi, M. (2025). Teachers’ working conditions, wellbeing and retention: An exploratory analysis to identify the key factors associated with teachers’ intention to leave. The Australian Educational Researcher, 52, 1947–1973.

•

Bryk, A. S., & Schneider, B. (2002). Trust in schools: A core resource for improvement. Russell Sage Foundation.

•

Edmondson, A. C., & Bransby, D. P. (2023). Psychological safety comes of age: Observed themes in an established literature. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 10, 55–78.

•

Farahmandpour, Z., & Voelkel, R. (2025). Teacher turnover factors and school-level influences: A meta-analysis of the literature. Education Sciences, 15(2), 219.

•

Liu, S., & Hallinger, P. (2024). The effects of instructional leadership, teacher responsibility and procedural justice climate on professional learning communities: A cross-level moderated mediation examination. Educational Management Administration & Leadership, 52(3), 556–575.

•

Toropova, A., Myrberg, E., & Johansson, S. (2021). Teacher job satisfaction: The importance of school working conditions and teacher characteristics. Educational Review, 73(1), 71–97.

•

Vo, D. T., Allen, K. A., & Reupert, A. (2026). Feeling heard and respected: Relational trust and teacher wellbeing in Australian schools. The Australian Educational Researcher, 53.

Meagan Booth is a Tennessee-based human resources supervisor and a former teacher and high school principal with 20 years of experience in the K–12 landscape. She writes and speaks about school leadership, HR realities in public school settings, putting policy into practice, and what real sustainability in education means.

Learn More

ASCD is a community dedicated to educators' professional growth and well-being.

Let us help you put your vision into action.
Discover ASCD's Professional Learning Services
Related Articles
View all
undefined
School & District Leadership
Trust Pillars, Trust Killers
Jen Schwanke
in 2 weeks

Related Articles

From our issue
The magazine cover for the issue "The Trust Factor", featuring two illustrated figures holding a tarp between them to catch the falling words "The Trust Factor"
The Trust Factor
Go To Publication