Teachers and school administrators depend on one another to do their work well. Teachers rely on principals and assistant principals to provide resources, support, and opportunities for professional growth, while administrators rely on teachers to translate school goals into instruction that supports student learning.
Trust between teachers and administrators fosters open communication, risk taking, and productive work toward shared goals. When teachers trust administrators, they may be more willing to engage with new initiatives, seek and act on their feedback, or ask for help. And when administrators trust teachers, they may be more willing to give them room to try new things and rely on their professional judgment about what will or will not work in their classrooms.
Because administrators have more formal authority than teachers, they hold the primary responsibility for building trust (Bryk & Schneider, 2002; Kochanek, 2005). They can create a trusting climate by getting to know teachers, providing authentic and constructive feedback on their instruction, and communicating with them honestly and transparently (Bukko et al., 2021).
What’s the role of teachers in this process? What power (if any) do they have in trust-building? And when administrators do not demonstrate trust, how might teachers respond? The Knowles Teacher Initiative and TERC, a nonprofit organization focused on STEM education research, partnered on a study to better understand this. We surveyed 66 teachers of varied genders, years of experience, and roles across 26 states and conducted in-depth interviews with seven of these teachers. The stories of three high school science and math teachers—Ellie, Kyle, and Ryan (all pseudonyms)—show how teachers’ experiences and contexts significantly shape how they cultivate trust with their administrators.
How Power Affects Trust
While administrators bear the greatest responsibility for growing trust in schools (Kochanek, 2005), trust and influence flow in both directions—from administrators to teachers and from teachers to administrators. Teachers depend on principals, but principals also depend on teachers (Bryk & Schneider, 2003). This interdependence creates important opportunities for teachers to shape these relationships.
There is no single, one-size-fits-all approach to how teachers can build trust with administrators. Instead, our research revealed that teachers’ approaches to trust-building were shaped by their situations, including previous interactions with administrators, the flow of power in these relationships, and the teachers’ and administrators’ perceptions of each other’s competence and credibility.
A common move among teachers involved showing vulnerability by making their own experimentation in the classroom visible to their administrators and remaining open to the feedback and support that might follow.
Ellie, for example, said that seeing her administrators take responsibility and acknowledge their mistakes increased her trust in them. Even after eight years of teaching, she feels vulnerable admitting she needs help, but because her administrators have been vulnerable with her, she is more willing to reveal her own classroom struggles and proactively ask them for support and feedback.
With over two decades of teaching experience, Kyle has led professional development, mentored new teachers, and opened up his classroom for others to observe. Yet interactions with some administrators left Kyle feeling misunderstood and unsupported. When this happened, Kyle didn’t retreat. Instead, he attempted to build a bridge by asking for feedback about new things he was trying. He’s already seen improvement in those relationships, even as he continues to work toward a more collaborative partnership. His willingness to take a risk and invite feedback built trust.
Although Ryan has a strong relationship with his associate principal now, their relationship faced a defining moment when the associate principal gave Ryan some difficult feedback about the impact of his behavior on colleagues and subsequently turned him down for a leadership position. Rather than shutting down, Ryan chose to lean into the feedback, which deepened the trust between them.
Two Strategies for Building Trust Upward
Our research found that the two most common strategies teachers used to build trust with administrators centered on classroom practice, a domain where teachers hold expertise and agency. By focusing on the classroom, teachers can build trust from a place where they have knowledge.
Classroom practice is of interest to principals because it is where the broader priorities of the school play out. Decisions about resources, policies, and staffing shape the learning experience. Therefore, it is a place of shared investment for both teachers and administrators.
Opening the Classroom
The most common way teachers sought to build trust involved intentionally focusing on classroom work and instructional practice during interactions with their administrators. For example, Ellie looked for ongoing opportunities to ask her administrators for constructive feedback. She made it clear that she wanted more from them than a pat on the back. By repeatedly inviting and responding to their feedback, she was asking them to invest in her and help her become a better teacher, which led to a more collaborative relationship.
How Ellie Opens Up Her Classroom
I’m just really open and proactively ask for feedback. I don’t want [my administrators] to just tell me ‘Here’s all the things that you’re doing that are a great job’ or ‘We know you’re a good teacher. Let me give you 5s out of 5s on everything.’ Instead [through inviting their feedback], I’m asking, ‘Hey, Can you invest in me? Can you make me a better teacher? Can you support me?’ I’m inviting a lot of that. It’s me giving them opportunities to show up, invest, help.
—Ellie, high school science teacher
Teachers also invited administrators into their classrooms for observations. Kyle, who felt unsupported by his supervisor, used these observations to test out new approaches that he wasn’t sure would work. For example, knowing that the school was engaged in an artificial intelligence initiative, he tried out an AI program he’d never used before while being observed. Taking these chances created opportunities for more open conversations with his supervisor.
Administrators typically supervise and evaluate teachers, but they don’t often partner with them. Both Ellie and Kyle sought to move administrators beyond their typical roles as evaluators and make them partners in collaborative conversations. These conversations strengthened trust by bringing teachers and administrators together to deliberate on problems of practice without clear solutions. Research suggests that shared decision making across differences of power can build trust (Kochanek, 2005).
Demonstrating Vulnerability
Another common move among teachers involved showing vulnerability by making their own experimentation in the classroom visible to their administrators and remaining open to the feedback and support that might follow. We saw this when Kyle took instructional risks in front of his supervisor.
Teachers also demonstrated vulnerability by remaining open and responsive to critique from administrators. After Ryan received difficult feedback from his associate principal, he took the critique seriously and worked to make changes. Importantly, he continued to make himself vulnerable by revisiting that feedback in later conversations and inviting his associate principal to assess his progress. He told us, “I think she really responded positively toward me checking in about that. . . . And now I’m volunteering things and she trusts me. She asks me for my opinion significantly more than she had in the past.”
Brené Brown (2018) defines vulnerability as “the emotion that we experience during times of uncertainty, risk, and emotional exposure.” Both Kyle and Ryan demonstrated vulnerability when they pursued conversations about their unpolished practices or behaviors. They risked judgment, increased scrutiny, or even pushback from their administrators. Similarly, Ellie worried about how her administrators would respond to her requests for help.
Ellie, Ryan, and Kyle all found that making oneself vulnerable can create meaningful opportunities for growth and deeper trust (Sussman, 2025). As Jill Harrison Berg (2018) writes, “We have to cultivate a climate that allows us to be comfortable with discomfort. We can’t learn from each other, solve previously unsolved problems, or come close to achieving higher hopes for our schools without taking risks.”
How Kyle Demonstrates Vulnerability
[I’ve made] myself vulnerable as an opportunity for [my supervisor and I] to work [together] and have a better relationship. I’ve tried things out that maybe I’ve never done before in an observation setting, where a lot of my colleagues would not choose [to], because it could affect their score.
—Kyle, high school science teacher
Assessing Your Trust Levels
The ways teachers build trust with their administrators are rooted in their professional goals, interests, and relationships. To foster a trusting and collaborative relationship with your administrator:
Evaluate your professional goals: How do they improve teaching and learning within or beyond your classroom? What challenges are you facing? What strengths have developed?
Evaluate your current relationship with your administrator: What have your prior interactions with them been like? How safe do you feel sharing your ideas, practice, and concerns? What expectations and norms might shape your interactions?
Evaluating your goals and relationship can help you decide how to increase trust with your administrator. Once you have a clear understanding of your goals and current relationship, consider how you could apply our strategies for building trust upward:
What classroom work or instructional practice could benefit from collaboration, increased attention, or additional support?
What might you gain (in your relationship, in your learning, in your students’ learning) from opening up your classroom practice to your administrator? What are the risks? Do the benefits outweigh the risks?
What role would you like administrators to take in your practice? How could you invite them into your work?
Trust is necessary for truly collaborative relationships that push learning deeper, improve teaching, and ultimately enrich students’ experiences. Although administrators bear the responsibility for building trust with teachers, teachers also have power to influence their relationships. Using their professional positions as instructional experts, teachers can invite their administrators into conversations about classroom practice. In doing so, they intentionally position them as trusted collaborators and partners in the work of schooling.